56-102 Monster coming down the pipeline

[gerardobrandao]

Proteus X524 Inisde

Hello Guys


Has soon has i ha oportunity i opened the back and took some pictures....
Has i told you, and i guess i wasn´t mistaken, TP 5850 motor is far superior to the X524 motor.....
As you can see from the pics, there is almost 0.6 inch from the back that doesn´t have "stator" area, wich leads to a "efective rotor" about the same lenght and diameter has the leopard 5692...
Only after trying it, i could lead to "real" performance opinion, but from speculation, i think it´s a deceptive motor...It´s like having a 527 cubic inch block, with 350 capacity....
Efective magnet length is 64mm about 2.52 inch!

Can anyone give input for stator efective length of leopard 5692 motor?









Best Regards

[Punisher 67]

Effective magnet lenght to a HK 5692 is 50.00mm long by 28.20mm in dia , interesting thing HK had some of the 5692 sized T20 motors Keith Bradley is selling and I happen to nab one - good thing they only had them for about two weeks and they are off the menu completely . Rotor size is 50.00mm long x 27.70mm in dia - both motors have virtually the same size rotor the difference could be just the wrap

The HK 5692 HAS 18 stacks and 6 magnetic segments
The T20 had 12 stacks and 4 magnet segments

The KV of both motors are in there 700's

[Brushless55]

Wow, looks like when I opened up a TP motor and a Leopard I have..
my pictures looked the same as these side by side

[gerardobrandao]

X 524 motor

Effective magnet lenght to a HK 5692 is 50.00mm long by 28.20mm in dia , interesting thing HK had some of the 5692 sized T20 motors Keith Bradley is selling and I happen to nab one - good thing they only had them for about two weeks and they are off the menu completely . Rotor size is 50.00mm long x 27.70mm in dia - both motors have virtually the same size rotor the difference could be just the wrap

The HK 5692 HAS 18 stacks and 6 magnetic segments
The T20 had 12 stacks and 4 magnet segments

The KV of both motors are in there 700's

Thanks for your input:

So the HK5692 is a 6 pole motor, against the 4 pole motor of the Leopard....didn´t know that, thats why one have 18 stacks and the other one 12...18/6=3=12/4

So...i see i was wrong...the X524 has a almost 30% higher rotor lenght....it may not tranform in more power, but it is a good start..

Other question, if anyone can help, since i think this is a good review for everyone....:

Can someone tell me (us) the length and diameter of the castle 2028 rotor length, for direct comparison against X524 motor!?

Best Regards to all

[ray schrauwen]

Effective magnet lenght to a HK 5692 is 50.00mm long by 28.20mm in dia , interesting thing HK had some of the 5692 sized T20 motors Keith Bradley is selling and I happen to nab one - good thing they only had them for about two weeks and they are off the menu completely . Rotor size is 50.00mm long x 27.70mm in dia - both motors have virtually the same size rotor the difference could be just the wrap

The HK 5692 HAS 18 stacks and 6 magnetic segments
The T20 had 12 stacks and 4 magnet segments

The KV of both motors are in there 700's

You will notice a difference even further, sorry I didn't take pic's but, the HOR SSS 1200kv version has a set screw on each end of the rotor and the inner stack & rotor of HOR 1200kv is 1/2" longer than the rotor of the Hobby King TP power 1320kv version. Many versions.

I've had many 5692's and kept the 1200Kv HOR motor as it runs very nice in my 40" mono.

[ray schrauwen]

The Proteus motor most likely the closest to a Castle 2028 would be the Proteus car motor. The X528 is much longer than the boat motors** and is rated at 780Kv, 7350 watts, Max 38Vdc, 193Amps Max, 1260 grams without a cooling jacket.

** Meaning the stack and rotor because the wires come out the side of the 112mm can enabling a longer stack & rotor, I'm assuming without having one here but, I pretty close me thinks...

BTW, HOR rates his motors at max 10,000 watts ???? ooops, says 12,000 watts for 5694 motor.

[ray schrauwen]

I just checked and Steve, OSE.. has New 112mm Leopards for sale. Now these are going to be very nice motors 4 sure.

[Azmarine]

I think price wise for motors this close in size and quality, proteus takes it with a sticker of $111.90 each for the 524-2t 910kv/1580kv. Especially if your going with twins shipping is the only hit, about $53 to Tucson. I think I'm going proteus twins in my drambuie. Keep in mind I am a newbie, but not dummy. I'd like to get a bit more feedback before I commit to this buy

[twissted]

There is a couple of places to get these motors from, another has better shipping. But the price is a little more. OSE sells them now so you will have to do your home work to find what I'm talking about.

[Cooper]

There is a couple of places to get these motors from, another has better shipping. But the price is a little more. OSE sells them now so you will have to do your home work to find what I'm talking about.

Why don't you just tell where els these are and be helpful?

[Azmarine]

Well the cheapest I've found is rcecho.com and they are 111.90 each I went thru the checkout process and for two shipped to my door it was $276.70. So far everywhere else wants about 160 or more per. That's just my little input.

[Punisher 67]

BTW, HOR rates his motors at max 10,000 watts ???? ooops, says 12,000 watts for 5694 motor.

12000 watts for a 5692 !!! - In a a pigs a$$.... , he's dreaming

[ray schrauwen]

Maybe so but, they are far different than TP power of the same numbers... I think TP Power has splintered up. Johnny said he hired some guys from TP to make motors to his spec, not TP specs.

12000 watts for a 5692 !!! - In a a pigs a$$.... , he's dreaming

[keithbradley]

Effective magnet lenght to a HK 5692 is 50.00mm long by 28.20mm in dia , interesting thing HK had some of the 5692 sized T20 motors Keith Bradley is selling and I happen to nab one - good thing they only had them for about two weeks and they are off the menu completely . Rotor size is 50.00mm long x 27.70mm in dia - both motors have virtually the same size rotor the difference could be just the wrap

The HK 5692 HAS 18 stacks and 6 magnetic segments
The T20 had 12 stacks and 4 magnet segments

The KV of both motors are in there 700's

The T20 motors that HK sells are not the same as a 524, they are shorter.
I have done comparisons on 5692, 524, and 2028 motors and I have tested the 524 motors. Each is it's own and doesn't compare to the others. I can assure you that none of these motors are the same size internally.

[Punisher 67]

Sorry Keith what I was trying to say was Skyrc the manufacturer of the 524 and 528 Proteus motors also make a buggy version . The 524 will have a 2.4 inch long rotor and the 528 will have a 2.8 inch long rotor . I will bet the farm that the rotors are all the same diameter as the 56 series motors TP's and HK's

http://www.skyrc.com/index.php?route=product/product&path=39_82&product_id=139