SAW propeller for Hydro 2

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Ivan Kozyakov
    Member
    • Apr 2022
    • 81

    #1

    SAW propeller for Hydro 2

    Hi guys!


    I am preparing my Hydro-2 for the next season with 8s SAW setup (2000 Kv SSS, 240A Swordfish). In many SAW videos I have seen that they use three bladed propellers. What are the advantages of such a solution? How do they differ from standard semi-submersible ones?

    IMG-1979.jpg
  • Bande1
    Senior Member
    • Mar 2023
    • 684

    #2
    they slip less

    Comment

    • NativePaul
      Greased Weasel
      • Feb 2008
      • 2759

      #3
      For a long time Octura's V series were the only props readily available with high pitch and lowish lift, and they are all 3 bladed.
      Paul Upton-Taylor, Greased Weasel Racing.

      Comment

      • Bande1
        Senior Member
        • Mar 2023
        • 684

        #4
        Originally posted by NativePaul
        For a long time Octura's V series were the only props readily available with high pitch and lowish lift, and they are all 3 bladed.
        as pitch increases, rake has to increase and/or blade area goes down. the prop has less bite on the water and thus 3 blades add blade area causing less slip. As rake increases lift decreases because the thrust cone becomes narrower.

        this is what the prop dudes tell me, anyway.

        Comment

        • Ivan Kozyakov
          Member
          • Apr 2022
          • 81

          #5
          Does this make sense for all three blade propellers? Or only for special ones SAW with low lift? Can I buy an inexpensive 1.8 pitch prop from Aliexpress for the first tests?

          HTB1FuCWXyDxK1RjSsD4q6z1DFXaR.jpg

          Comment

          • Bande1
            Senior Member
            • Mar 2023
            • 684

            #6
            you got to be careful because 2000kv is extremely high for 8s and youre very likely to destroy something. You really need to lower the RPM and raise the prop sizes. or get a TP competition motor rated for those RPM's. 1000-1400kv is much more appropriate outside the very specific high RPM motors that have extra kevlar around the magnets to turn that fast.

            once you get that under control you need to use the prop calculator to find out where you need to be. you have to start off slower and monitor temps. thats absolutely critical to start slow.

            Comment

            • LibertyMKiii
              Senior Member
              • Dec 2018
              • 127

              #7
              I am interested in trying 3 blades as well.
              My logical conclusion is that having a blade in the water 33% more often per RPM will net a much higher load on the motor. It would be wise to start with a 2 blade and see where things are with temperatures and then move to a 3 blade.

              Having a higher amperage draw will result in lower RPMs and in some cases this is why more blades = less top speed. The setup has to be optimized for 3 blades.

              Comment

              • Ivan Kozyakov
                Member
                • Apr 2022
                • 81

                #8
                Originally posted by Bande1
                you got to be careful because 2000kv is extremely high for 8s and youre very likely to destroy something. You really need to lower the RPM and raise the prop sizes. or get a TP competition motor rated for those RPM's. 1000-1400kv is much more appropriate outside the very specific high RPM motors that have extra kevlar around the magnets to turn that fast.

                once you get that under control you need to use the prop calculator to find out where you need to be. you have to start off slower and monitor temps. thats absolutely critical to start slow.
                Yes, I understand the risk, but I want to do this for the sake of experimentation before buying a new motor. Moreover, according to the calculator load RMP will be 49K, the maximum for this motor is 50K by manual. My current setup is 6s+46mm/1.8 pitch prop and the motor is a little warm.

                Comment

                • Speed2
                  Junior Member
                  • Jun 2023
                  • 24

                  #9
                  The abc 1820 22 45 2 blade. For saw runs you may get away with the 2000kv on 8s. You just have to make sure you have proper cooling. Also the 240amp swordfish is like not going to be good for a setup like this. The castle creation hydra is likely going to be the best esc for your goal. The hydra is an 8s capable esc that will handle well over 300amps for a saw setup.

                  Comment

                  • Veloctiykingsracing
                    Junior Member
                    • Oct 2021
                    • 15

                    #10
                    2000kv is absolutely fine for 8s SAW runs. As mentioned, go w a hydra, check your data. The Swordfish is much less forgiving. If the data suggests your amp load is within range for using the Swordfish, then use it.

                    Comment

                    • Bande1
                      Senior Member
                      • Mar 2023
                      • 684

                      #11
                      Originally posted by Veloctiykingsracing
                      2000kv is absolutely fine for 8s SAW runs. As mentioned, go w a hydra, check your data. The Swordfish is much less forgiving. If the data suggests your amp load is within range for using the Swordfish, then use it.
                      you dont even know what size it is. the biggest SSS 2000kv is a 4092 rated for 23v max and 4200w peak, which is only 150A on 8s.

                      Comment

                      • Ivan Kozyakov
                        Member
                        • Apr 2022
                        • 81

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Bande1
                        you dont even know what size it is. the biggest SSS 2000kv is a 4092 rated for 23v max and 4200w peak, which is only 150A on 8s.

                        https://tflnorthamerica.com/wp-conte...ist-2020-2.pdf
                        4082 2000kv, 31v Max. And even 60K RMP Max

                        H4800cf9311c74d02917fe17ae1cfb4b.jpg

                        Comment

                        • Veloctiykingsracing
                          Junior Member
                          • Oct 2021
                          • 15

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Bande1
                          you dont even know what size it is. the biggest SSS 2000kv is a 4092 rated for 23v max and 4200w peak, which is only 150A on 8s.

                          https://tflnorthamerica.com/wp-conte...ist-2020-2.pdf
                          Again, it would be fine for an 8s SAW run. Do I have to buy one and prove it?

                          Comment

                          • Bande1
                            Senior Member
                            • Mar 2023
                            • 684

                            #14
                            you see that 3200w rating? 3200w / 28v = 114A

                            Comment

                            • Bande1
                              Senior Member
                              • Mar 2023
                              • 684

                              #15
                              Originally posted by Veloctiykingsracing
                              Again, it would be fine for an 8s SAW run. Do I have to buy one and prove it?
                              yeah and do it with an 1820. be fun.

                              Comment

                              Working...