Props 3 blade vs 2 blade

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • H&MWill
    Senior Member
    • Apr 2007
    • 623

    #1

    Props 3 blade vs 2 blade

    I am running an Octura x645 right now and it is the best i have found yet. I like it better than the Prather 220 and the x642. My question is would I get more or less speed out of a 3 blade Grim prop? If you think it would be more which one would you suggest? Thanks guys
    Many issues!!!
  • Flying Scotsman
    Fast Electric Adict!
    • Jun 2007
    • 5190

    #2
    Originally posted by H&MWill
    I am running an Octura x645 right now and it is the best i have found yet. I like it better than the Prather 220 and the x642. My question is would I get more or less speed out of a 3 blade Grim prop? If you think it would be more which one would you suggest? Thanks guys
    An X645 is a very aggresive prop, what is your set up? How does your boat run and turn. What are the temps with your present set up?

    Comment

    • H&MWill
      Senior Member
      • Apr 2007
      • 623

      #3
      Hi, I am using OSE trim tabs 12 cell 3600's. Octura water pick up. The boat runs very well turns nicely. The Prather was the one that seemed to make it handle the worse. Didnt like the turns at all. With the current setup everything is cool. The motor barely gets warm to the touch. The packs get the hottest like 120. The esc is around 90. Thanks
      Many issues!!!

      Comment

      • Flying Scotsman
        Fast Electric Adict!
        • Jun 2007
        • 5190

        #4
        Will, my suggestion would be 4S1P or 3S1P and an X440/3. Look at some other threads as far as props are concerned, bigger is not always the answer for more speed

        Comment

        • H&MWill
          Senior Member
          • Apr 2007
          • 623

          #5
          Ok cool thanks. I will have to wait a little while wifey has cut my boat budget since the holidays are coming. LOL
          Many issues!!!

          Comment

          • Ctonez
            Senior Member
            • Jul 2007
            • 404

            #6
            I prefer 3 blade. I'm not too sure of the theory behind it, I think more blade in the water at all times is good for this boat's stability...that's the case in my experience.

            I ran a detounged 440/3 with Nimhs/Lipos (otherwise stock) and a 437/3 with Lipos & the Ammo.

            Comment

            • H&MWill
              Senior Member
              • Apr 2007
              • 623

              #7
              Yeah, I wasnt sure of theory either. The only three blade I ran was the stock one which is horrible since its plastic. I would like to try lipos just been puttin it off since I know nothing at all about them. I am afraid I'll just spend my money and do something to screw em up. The only other person I have been running with is my dad and he runs the same setup.
              Many issues!!!

              Comment

              • Flying Scotsman
                Fast Electric Adict!
                • Jun 2007
                • 5190

                #8
                Will, I trust that props such as X645 have been ballanced and sharpenned??

                If, not you will have numerous problems.

                Comment

                • H&MWill
                  Senior Member
                  • Apr 2007
                  • 623

                  #9
                  Yes sir all of the props I mentioned are. Oh yeah if I switch to the lipos that you mentioned do I need 2 packs or 1? Also how would I wire them up to the stock ESC?
                  Last edited by H&MWill; 10-29-2007, 02:02 PM. Reason: forgot a word.
                  Many issues!!!

                  Comment

                  • Flying Scotsman
                    Fast Electric Adict!
                    • Jun 2007
                    • 5190

                    #10
                    Will. review Jay Turners article in a recent RRC Boat Modelling to answer your questions. As parallel and series make a huge difference, but the end result is voltage and amperage capability

                    Comment

                    • H&MWill
                      Senior Member
                      • Apr 2007
                      • 623

                      #11
                      Sounds good I'll pick it up 2nite. Thanks again.
                      Many issues!!!

                      Comment

                      • Bill-SOCAL
                        Fast Electric Addict!
                        • Nov 2007
                        • 1404

                        #12
                        GrimRacer 42x55 2-blade. Made a huge difference over the stock prop. Boat gets up on plane faster and runs faster. Batteries and motor warm, but not hot, at end of 7 minute run.
                        Don't get me started

                        Comment

                        • Avanti
                          Fast Electric Addict!
                          • Nov 2007
                          • 1280

                          #13
                          I have one and I would not recomend the 3 blade grim prop as it is total weak sauce. the 42x55grim works well out of the few I have tried so far.
                          The Manx has been sitting dormant, but I think I finally have my motivation back. I hope to see it float soon.

                          Comment

                          • Avanti
                            Fast Electric Addict!
                            • Nov 2007
                            • 1280

                            #14
                            I was wrong about the 40x52/3 (41.6mph) with the right batteries (trinity 7.2v 4200mah) this prop is faster than the 42x55 (37.1mph) because it is a bit more stable.

                            the proboat 1.6x2.5 is a decent prop for a box stock sv, as it will give you the stern lift you need with the batteries in their factory location.
                            The Manx has been sitting dormant, but I think I finally have my motivation back. I hope to see it float soon.

                            Comment

                            • zero9046
                              Member
                              • Oct 2007
                              • 41

                              #15
                              More food for thought...

                              Yesterday I was out at the pond and got some "record" numbers (at least for myself).

                              Wind 20-25 (the pond was fairly protected though)
                              Slight Chop

                              SV27 with:
                              Ammo 2300kv
                              14.4v cheapo 3300's
                              BSP Octura 440/3
                              38.8mph

                              14.4v IB4200's (that have seen better days)
                              440/3
                              45.1mph


                              Personally, I like the 3 blade octura better. I have ran with the stock prop, Graupner CF 45's and 48's, and the x642, but this has been the best all around prop.

                              Keep in mind, my top speed runs were downwind, so I'm not sure how much it "helped" my speed. (btw, anyone know if that kind of wind would give my boat 5mph more that without? i was really excited yesterday because I have been dying to break 40 for quiet a while)

                              Finally got a clear picture of the GPS, so I thought I'd throw that in.

                              Last edited by zero9046; 01-09-2008, 03:03 AM. Reason: added picture

                              Comment

                              Working...