Prop, and rudder relationship

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • runzwithsizorz
    Senior Member
    • Jan 2009
    • 896

    #1

    Prop, and rudder relationship

    The trailing edge of my rudder is an inch passed my prop. Can this effect thrust? and/or steering? Am I worrying too much?
    I know aesthetically it *looks* a whole lot better when they are even, or the rudder is slightly ahead.Also think my rudder is
    too long, (almost 3" deeper than shaft), if I shorten it should I leave it squared as it is now? or can round the leading edge
    just a bit? It always seemed to me that by doing so, the rudder would be less inclined to snag on stuff.
  • SirBudman32
    Senior Member
    • Aug 2011
    • 625

    #2
    Don't round leading edge you want it sharp like a knife.
    Modified Jae21, Stock Jae21, Cheetah, Ul-1, Shock Wave 26 V2 (Rescue Boat).

    Comment

    • JIM MARCUM
      Senior Member
      • Jun 2011
      • 773

      #3
      I'd cut the rudder down so about 1 1/2" is below the bottom of the prop shaft. If the water pickup is exposed on the tip, seal it with a dab of thickened epoxy (add shredded fiberglass until it's like wood putty). I use a 8" rouge wheel to sharpen the rudder like a knife from the bottom tip to 1" above the waterline. Have the the cuts to prove it. JIM
      JIM MARCUM: NAMBA 777; EX? SoCal FE Racers Club; D-19; Official 2012 NAMBA FE Nationals Rescue Diver; Purple Heart Viet Nam Vet; Professional SCUBA/HOOKA Diver, KELCO, 1973-1978; BBA 1978, Magna Cum Laude; MBA 1980 w/honors; Retired DOD GS1102-12 Contract Specialist

      Comment

      • runzwithsizorz
        Senior Member
        • Jan 2009
        • 896

        #4
        Originally posted by SirBudman32
        Don't round leading edge you want it sharp like a knife.
        I guess I said that wrong. I did not mean dulling the edge, but sweeping back/tampering/rounding off, the bottom part of the rudder from for, to aft. Like this, only just a bit more so.

        ose-80052.JPG
        Last edited by runzwithsizorz; 03-27-2012, 06:26 PM.

        Comment

        • SirBudman32
          Senior Member
          • Aug 2011
          • 625

          #5
          sharp leading, round bottom, square on the back.
          Modified Jae21, Stock Jae21, Cheetah, Ul-1, Shock Wave 26 V2 (Rescue Boat).

          Comment

          • JIM MARCUM
            Senior Member
            • Jun 2011
            • 773

            #6
            Do not round off the rudder tips. Sharp leading edge, flat bottom parallel to the water, trailing edge flat with sharp edges. Objective is to cleanly shear thru the water without unecessary drag. JIM
            JIM MARCUM: NAMBA 777; EX? SoCal FE Racers Club; D-19; Official 2012 NAMBA FE Nationals Rescue Diver; Purple Heart Viet Nam Vet; Professional SCUBA/HOOKA Diver, KELCO, 1973-1978; BBA 1978, Magna Cum Laude; MBA 1980 w/honors; Retired DOD GS1102-12 Contract Specialist

            Comment

            • JIM MARCUM
              Senior Member
              • Jun 2011
              • 773

              #7
              Do not round off the rudder tips. Sharp leading edge, flat bottom parallel to the water, trailing edge flat with sharp edges. Objective is to cleanly shear thru the water horizontally without needless drag. JIM
              JIM MARCUM: NAMBA 777; EX? SoCal FE Racers Club; D-19; Official 2012 NAMBA FE Nationals Rescue Diver; Purple Heart Viet Nam Vet; Professional SCUBA/HOOKA Diver, KELCO, 1973-1978; BBA 1978, Magna Cum Laude; MBA 1980 w/honors; Retired DOD GS1102-12 Contract Specialist

              Comment

              • runzwithsizorz
                Senior Member
                • Jan 2009
                • 896

                #8
                Originally posted by JIM MARCUM
                I'd cut the rudder down so about 1 1/2" is below the bottom of the prop shaft. If the water pickup is exposed on the tip, seal it with a dab of thickened epoxy (add shredded fiberglass until it's like wood putty). I use a 8" rouge wheel to sharpen the rudder like a knife from the bottom tip to 1" above the waterline. Have the the cuts to prove it. JIM
                Unfortunately, the water inlets are really low on this rudder, so I can only trim off a little bit more the an inch. I *could* re-drill the inlets, (this is a dual pick-up), higher but that's a lot of work for half an inch. I use J&B weld BTW.

                Comment

                • JIM MARCUM
                  Senior Member
                  • Jun 2011
                  • 773

                  #9
                  Thats fine. I wouldn't screw up the twin inlet rudder, just eliminate any excess length to reduce hydrodynamic drag. JB Weld is cool too. Good luck with your build. JIM
                  JIM MARCUM: NAMBA 777; EX? SoCal FE Racers Club; D-19; Official 2012 NAMBA FE Nationals Rescue Diver; Purple Heart Viet Nam Vet; Professional SCUBA/HOOKA Diver, KELCO, 1973-1978; BBA 1978, Magna Cum Laude; MBA 1980 w/honors; Retired DOD GS1102-12 Contract Specialist

                  Comment

                  • Fluid
                    Fast and Furious
                    • Apr 2007
                    • 8012

                    #10
                    Guys, shortening the rudder could be absolutely the wrong thing to do. The drag penalty is minor at normal oval speeds, and you will lose a lot more speed if you have to use a lot of left rudder trim to keep the boat going straight. The rudder is all that keeps the transom from drifting to the right from prop walk on many hulls once they are at speed. Not enough side resistance to prop walk from the rudder blade and you may need a lot of left trim = drag. The "best" way to find out the minimum amount of rudder a particular hull needs is to keep trimming off the rudder in 1/4" steps until you have gone too far, then buy a new rudder and cut it just a bit longer.

                    Too, on deep vees with the rudder on the right, banking left into a turn means most of the rudder comes out of the water = minimal control. Lay the boat on its bottom left side and see how much rudder is in the water. A good minimum is 1-1/4", more doesn't hurt. All this worry about drag and we forget that we still have to control the models......
                    ERROR 403 - This is not the page you are looking for

                    Comment

                    • JIM MARCUM
                      Senior Member
                      • Jun 2011
                      • 773

                      #11
                      Jay is absolutely right. My recommended rudder length of 1 1/2" below the bottom of the strut was intended for cats only, and even then aiming at those looking for the absolute max speed with thier setup. If you are happy with how your boat handles & it's speed - leave it alone. Want less drag - listen to what Jay wrote on steps to fix it. JIM
                      JIM MARCUM: NAMBA 777; EX? SoCal FE Racers Club; D-19; Official 2012 NAMBA FE Nationals Rescue Diver; Purple Heart Viet Nam Vet; Professional SCUBA/HOOKA Diver, KELCO, 1973-1978; BBA 1978, Magna Cum Laude; MBA 1980 w/honors; Retired DOD GS1102-12 Contract Specialist

                      Comment

                      • runzwithsizorz
                        Senior Member
                        • Jan 2009
                        • 896

                        #12
                        GOT IT, Thankz guyz. I must say i rather admire Fluids' approach,------- fix it till ya break it.

                        Comment

                        Working...