Holy crap!! Yeah, that's a good reason for me to just buy more chargers instead of rolling the dice on parallel charging. Yikes!
Where do you store your batteries?
Collapse
X
-
Up until that point I thought parallel charging was just the best thing ever but after what I am now calling "The Great fire of 2017" I did some research and have found several similar problems on other non-boat related RC forums to do with parallel charging, it's not a rare occurrence. Possibly being diligent and making double sure your packs are healthy with similar voltages as well as charging at a lower rate should help this problem but I am still not going to take the risk of parallel charging again. Us boaters are pretty hard on our packs and it doesn't take long to start weakening packs, it's only a matter of time until there is a weak link in a pack, even a cell checker does not tell anywhere near the full story of your cells health.Comment
-
Not that I will do it, but I have not heard of parallel charging. Multiple packs on the same port?
Lone-Wolf as I said earlier between your testimony and watching a nearby home burn to the ground last weekend, you have this kid thinking. I probably would have just kept thinking about it all summer but done nothing. Not so now, so thank you.May your batteries never fail you...
MikeComment
-
Not that I will do it, but I have not heard of parallel charging. Multiple packs on the same port?
Lone-Wolf as I said earlier between your testimony and watching a nearby home burn to the ground last weekend, you have this kid thinking. I probably would have just kept thinking about it all summer but done nothing. Not so now, so thank you.
Here's a link to the setup I was running with the parallel boards, could actually have 6 packs charging/channel at up to 80 amps/channel on that setup! I had to have two power supplies to run this beast!...not anymore, I only do one pack/channel now at 5 amps and ya know what?...still feel pretty manly about it LOL!
Comment
-
That rig looks kinda scary to me.
Coincidentally, my 4 port charger lost a port a few weeks back so I need to send it in for warranty work. Didn't want to be without a charger for who knows how long so I ordered another 4 port charger today. When the other one comes back, I hope with 8 ports available I won't have need for anything other than 1/1 charging.
Going fridge shopping tomorrowMay your batteries never fail you...
MikeComment
-
I put mine in the mini fridge, they are about 45 degrees, and take about 30 minutes to warm up to 65 degrees which is about what my basement is typically.NEVER SATISFIED RACING
Fine Design 32 V-Hull 4082+6sComment
-
I store mine in an old cleaned out BBQ under my deck, holds everything and is of course flame-proof! A couple months ago I had a serious fire while parallel charging a bunch of 6S packs, had I not been right there it would have been game over, what a mess too. Now I am super paranoid and charge at 1C max rate and never parallel charge. Once you have a fire it changes you forever, while I was putting the flames out I was thinking "that's it for this crazy hobby"...an hour later I was feeling better but I don't like even keeping storage charged lipo's inside my house anywhere. I believe this is a place where overkill is OK.Comment
-
Further up the thread I explained that I used a garden hose and there's a link to my charging setup 3 posts above. I can only guess at the actual problem, most likely a cell that did not want to come up to voltage while the others in the parallel string did so the charger continued putting amps into it which heated it and puffed it up until it exploded. All in all it's pretty sketchy, I would not parallel charge unless it was outside, maybe you'll be OK for a number of years doing this but all it takes is one time and it seems like it's an eventuality at some point especially for us FE guys that put our packs through alot more than the average car/truck or airplane guy.Comment
-
Up until that point I thought parallel charging was just the best thing ever but after what I am now calling "The Great fire of 2017" I did some research and have found several similar problems on other non-boat related RC forums to do with parallel charging, it's not a rare occurrence. Possibly being diligent and making double sure your packs are healthy with similar voltages as well as charging at a lower rate should help this problem but I am still not going to take the risk of parallel charging again. Us boaters are pretty hard on our packs and it doesn't take long to start weakening packs, it's only a matter of time until there is a weak link in a pack, even a cell checker does not tell anywhere near the full story of your cells health.Comment
-
Man, if I had a good consistent 65 degree place to do my maintenance and storage, I wouldn't be thinking about a fridge. As a matter of fact, I was planning on running the fridge about 55-60. You do bring up a good point. Do you need to let the batteries warm up before you put them on a charger?May your batteries never fail you...
MikeComment
-
Man, if I had a good consistent 65 degree place to do my maintenance and storage, I wouldn't be thinking about a fridge. As a matter of fact, I was planning on running the fridge about 55-60. You do bring up a good point. Do you need to let the batteries warm up before you put them on a charger?Vac-U-Tug Jr (13mph)Comment
-
-
Was charging with my brand new but now scorched to hell expensive Revo charger, has two channels and was running two parallel boards, one/channel of course. Each board had 4x Revo 5000ma 70C 4.20 Gopacks connected, only a few runs on the packs, I would run all 8 packs total in my 73" Mystic at 12S2P/side...so was nice to be able to charge everything at once. Anyways, was charging at 2C so each pack would see up to 10 amps, 40 amps total/channel. Near the end of the charge cycle I can hear a "ticking" sound that I already know from other packs exploding but not catching fire from a year prior. I immediately ran into the room where I was charging and turned everything off but I was petrified to unplug the packs without a face shield so I just stood well back...a minute later KABOOM!!!...cell ruptures and almost immediately a roaring inferno erupts out of that pack with flames literally to the ceiling!!! Man alive that was the worst thing to experience. Luckily I have a garden hose right around the corner outside so doused the flames and they went out in under 30 seconds but the smoke was nuts!!! The 12'x12' room was solid smoke and had to breathe through my shirt while down on my knees while holding the hose. I know that having a fire extinguisher or sand is a nice thing to have nearby but a garden hose running full blast worked very well...but the smoke!! All I can say is it was total carnage and a huge mess, I ended up losing 6x6S packs, 2 went up in smoke while the other 4 were just damaged from the heat and no way am I going to run them again plus burned all my chargers and my nice work desk, I would say I lost $1000 easily in packs, a charger and a power supply plus cleanup. Took hours to clear the smoke, wife wasn't too impressed and you can imagine how many times I heard her nattering in the background about quitting this silly hobby LOL! Anyhow, was a terrible experience but I am thankful nobody was hurt and I was there just in time. Honestly guys, had it been only 60 seconds more it's possible I would not have had that fire under control, 3 minutes later?....game over. I hope this can stick in all your minds and you'll take the time and spend a little bit of money to keep things safe for you and your family.
In the end, to answer the original question, I a certain what actually happened was one cell in that one pack that was "ticking" was not coming up to the 4.20v threshold while all the rest were, time and continuous charge caused the cell to rupture and blow, the blow is pretty violent when it happens and usually that's all that does happen but in this case it must have caused a short in the pack and BLAM! I now always use my cell checker before I charge a pack, was obviously far more important to do this if you are parallel charging but should you see a cell that is well under voltage of the others it's pretty suspect as most of you should know, I would not take the risk. It's really too bad that even the best cells money can buy with a top charger is still not enough to keep you safe. I hope one day we can look back at these times and be thankful we have technology that is totally safe but until then figure something out ASAP!Comment
Comment